Bengal budget session minus Governor Bose, sources in TMC cite fig leaf of sine die
Telegraph | 7 February 2024
The Budget session of the Bengal Assembly started on Monday without the conventional speech by governor C.V. Ananda Bose amid apprehensions of a fresh round of confrontation between the Mamata Banerjee government and Raj Bhavan.
Multiple officials and senior legislators claimed in recent memory this was the first time that a Budget session in the Bengal Assembly started without a speech by the governor.
"It is conventional that every Budget session starts with the governor's speech. This year the convention was not followed," said a source in the Assembly.
Though the office of Bose did not release any statement on it, multiple sources confirmed that Raj Bhavan was contemplating "action" for the breach in convention.
"No budget session can begin without the speech of the governor and it did not happen earlier. Raj Bhavan is observing the developments and contemplating its further course of action," said a source in Raj Bhavan.
Speaker Biman Banerjee, when asked about the reason behind starting the Budget session without the governor's speech, said he would speak on the issue inside the House on Tuesday.
"Whatever I have to say about the governor's speech, will say inside the House tomorrow," he told mediapersons.
Several veteran Trinamul legislators claimed that the governor's speech was not necessary because the previous session had been adjourned sine die and the House was only reconvened on Monday.
"There is no controversy or questions over the governor's speech as the session was a continuation of the earlier session. If an ongoing session was not dissolved, then there is no question of starting it with the speech," said Manas Bhuniya, a senior MLA and minister in Mamata Banerjee's cabinet.
However, a senior official at Raj Bhavan raised the question of how the state government can present two Budgets in a financial year if the Budget session was a continuation of the previous one.
The official said: "We have two questions. First, if it is a fresh Bdget session, then how it was started without the governor's speech? Second, if it was a continuation of its earlier session, then how the state government can pass two budgets in a year?""The government is yet to send the Budget copy to governor C.V. Ananda Bose," he added.
Some insiders said that the Mamata Banerjee government had been trying to avoid the governor's speech because of past experiences.
"Jagdeep Dhankhar, the predecessor of the current governor, desired to add some new points to his budget speech that became an embarrassment for the government. I think the ruling dispensation intentionally adjourned the previous session sine die to skip the governor's speech," said a minister.
However, a source in the Assembly said that the governor could follow his predecessor Dhankhar and prorogue (discontinue) the ongoing session by using his powers before starting a new session in the Assembly.
Assembly proceedings on Monday were adjourned after mentioning eminent figures who died recently such as singer and former Trinamul MLA Anup Ghosal, renowned classical vocalist Ustad Rashid Khan and former CPM MLA Maharani Konar.