Mamata Banerjee head injury: 'Push from behind' narrative scaled down
Telegraph | 16 March 2024
As chief minister Mamata Banerjee recovered from Thursday night’s forehead gash sustained at home, the “push from behind” narrative was given a swift burial and the police registered no complaint.
A physician spoke of the possibility of a person having “a sensation of a push”, a theory Trinamul immediately latched on to.
Senior police officers said they had till late Friday evening not received any complaint saying the chief minister’s fall at home on Thursday evening was caused by a push.
“The police can’t draw up an FIR under IPC Section 325 (voluntarily causing grievous hurt) unless the victim or a witness lodges a formal complaint,” an officer said.
A relative had alleged a “push from behind” before reporters on Thursday night — after Mamata suffered cuts on her forehead and nose from a fall and was taken to SSKM Hospital where she was given stitches.
Shortly before the relative’s allegation, the SSKM director, Dr Manimoy Bandyopadhyay, had issued a statement that too spoke of a “push from behind” and set the cat among the pigeons. On Friday, Bandopadhyay said he had been “misinterpreted”.
“Chief minister Mamata Banerjee reported to our hospital at around 7.30pm, with a history of fall, within the vicinity of her home, due to some push from behind,” Bandopadhyay had said on Thursday.
The “push from behind” part of the statement went viral on social media within minutes, generated debate in the mainstream media, and spawned conspiracy theories in poll season.
Bandyopadhyay clarified on Friday he had only meant Mamata may have experienced “a sensation of a push”.
“This was a sensation of a push from
behind, which led to the fall…. Our job is to treat, and we have done that.
There was a misinterpretation of what I said last evening,” the SSKM director
told journalists.
“The chief minister had probably tried to say that at the time of the
fall, she had felt the sensation of a push from
behind. That does not imply somebody had pushed her.”
Trinamul fielded industry minister Shashi Panja — herself a physician —
to buttress the “sensation of a push” theory. Panja endorsed Bandopadhyay’s
clarification.
“There is this strange element that has become a talking point — that
somebody had pushed her.
Nothing like this happened. It’s very clear,” Panja said.
“I too am a doctor. We understand that there was no pushing involved. Sometimes there is a
sensation, amid discomfort in the body… it’s possible for a person to stumble
during that… some sensation perhaps,” she added.
“For that, suddenly there could be a case of tripping as well… that
caused her to fall. Thereafter, she got seriously injured. But that
strange theory, or what it implies,
made this rather weird…. None of that is true.”
Officially, the CPM, Congress and the BJP had stayed largely mum on
Mamata’s injury except for sending brief get-well messages, perhaps remembering
how counterproductive their mockery of her leg injury ahead of the 2021
Assembly polls had turned out to be.
However, some comments seemed to express scepticism. One of them came
from Midnapore MP and former state BJP chief Dilip Ghosh.
“There are many elements to this. A lot of people are demanding
answers…. She is the Number One person in this state. How did she get injured
like that in her own room? It should be properly investigated,” Ghosh said
early on Friday morning.
Later, the BJP’s Nandigram MLA, Suvendu Adhikari, was accused of mocking
Mamata over the fall at a rally in Khejuri.
A video clip circulated by Trinamul purportedly showed a man resembling
Adhikari saying: “Trinamul is going through a difficult time. Their heads are
spinning and they have been falling.”
Trinamul women’s wing chief and finance minister Chandrima Bhattacharya
accused Adhikari of misogyny.
“Attacking the only female CM is not just despicable – it’s a display of
contemptible misogyny,” the party said in a statement on X, quoting
Bhattacharya.
“@SuvenduWB’s shameful assault on Smt. @MamataOfficial, while she’s
receiving treatment. His words reek of desperation and an utter lack of basic
human decency. He must issue a sincere APOLOGY NOW.”
Mamata is believed to have hit her forehead against an object with sharp
edges — probably a showcase — as she fell. Apart from the cuts on the forehead
and nose, she seems to have suffered no great damage, doctors have said.
Police commissioner Vineet Kumar Goyal visited Mamata’s home on Friday
morning accompanied by other senior officers, but no meeting took place with
her.
Sources said the security ring around the Kalighat house had been
tightened, with arriving vehicles having to navigate additional layers of
security checks.
They added that Mamata was in her bedroom for most of the day, getting
her injuries tended to. She responded via posts on X to the get-well messages
sent by senior politicians from across the country, including Prime Minister
Narendra Modi and Congress leader Rahul Gandhi.
“The chief minister is clinically stable,” said a senior doctor at SSKM
Hospital.
Arrangements had been made at SSKM’s Woodburn Ward on Friday afternoon
for a visit by Mamata for a check-up. She, however, didn’t turn up. Instead, a
medical team went to her home.
Doctors have advised the chief minister to rest for a few days. Her
vital signs will be regularly monitored.
She is expected to step out and resume campaigning after a medical team
gives the nod, health department sources said.